A compliance program can only correct what it hears about, so having clear lines of communication for employees to report compliance concerns can help an organization identify and mitigate risk. If there is no reporting mechanism, an organization risks having the concern reported externally directly to a regulator, which could result in a more formal investigation or dispute.
Channels running up. Offer several: the direct supervisor, the compliance officer, a hotline, a web form, an email address. Different people report different things through different routes, and a single channel guarantees that anyone uncomfortable with that channel stays silent.
Offer anonymous reporting, and be honest in the policy about the difference between anonymous and confidential. Anonymity cannot always survive an investigation, because sometimes the substance of a report identifies the reporter.
Make the channels usable by your workforce: the languages your staff speak, access for employees without desks or organizational email, availability on nights and weekends, and coverage for contractors and vendors, who are frequently the first to see problems in referral relationships because they sit outside the organization’s internal politics.
Non-retaliation in practice. The False Claims Act's anti-retaliation provision, 31 U.S.C. § 3730(h), gives an employee who suffers retaliation for protected conduct a separate cause of action with its own remedies, including reinstatement and double back pay. A manageable compliance issue can become a second, independent piece of litigation because of how the organization treated the person who raised it.
OIG emphasizes tracking, and a compliance report log helps an organization show how it actually meets this element in practice. A hotline with no log is unmeasurable. A hotline that generates no reports is usually evidence that employees either do not know one exists, or believe nothing happens when a report is made. Providing some feedback to those who report compliance concerns help to build trust that the organization takes reports seriously and investigates them.
When a report reveals a real problem, it may require further investigation and corrective actions. Identifying an overpayment can start a 60-day clock on an obligation to refund, so reports should be acted on promptly.
Closing Thoughts
- Several channels beat one good one, and an anonymous option with honest limitations beats a confidentiality promise you cannot guarantee.
- The hotline log, covering intake, triage, disposition, and what the reporter was told, is the evidence this element is satisfied.
Kaufman & Canoles' Health Care Practice Group represents health care providers in compliance, regulatory, and transactional matters, with experience working with all types of healthcare organizations. Please reach out to Colin McCarthy or any member of the Health Care Practice Group with any questions.
- Of Counsel
Colin McCarthy is a healthcare regulatory attorney with more than 15 years of experience advising healthcare providers on compliance, reimbursement, and operational matters. Based in Richmond, Virginia, he advises clients ...