Photo of ESOP Valuation After the Retire Through Ownership Act: What Changed - and What Did Not

ESOP Valuation After the Retire Through Ownership Act: What Changed - and What Did Not

Article
Circle Arrow Get the Story

Article 1 of the four-part “ESOP Valuation After the Retire Through Ownership Act” series

Valuation sits at the center of every transaction involving an employee stock ownership plan, or ESOP. When an ESOP acquires shares of a privately held company, there is no public trading price to establish what the shares are worth. Instead, the ESOP trustee or other named fiduciary must determine, in good faith, the fair market value of the stock based on an independent appraisal and the surrounding facts and circumstances.

The “Retire Through Ownership Act”, Public Law 119-124, provides important statutory clarity for that process. Signed into law on October 15, 2026, the Act amended section 3(18) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), which defines “adequate consideration” for purposes of ERISA’s fiduciary and prohibited-transaction provisions. The amendment expressly recognizes that an ESOP fiduciary may rely in good faith on a valuation prepared by an independent valuation expert or business appraiser using the principles and methodologies of Internal Revenue Service Revenue Ruling 59-60.[1]

That clarification matters, but its limits matter just as much. The Act does not make an appraisal conclusive. It does not validate a transaction price merely because an independent valuation report exists. And it does not alter a fiduciary’s duties of prudence and loyalty under ERISA section 404.

A sound independent appraisal remains essential. But it remains one component of a broader, prudent, and well-documented fiduciary process.

Why “Adequate Consideration” Matters in an ESOP Transaction

ERISA generally prohibits certain transactions between an employee benefit plan and a “party in interest,” a term that may include the sponsoring employer and selling shareholders. A statutory exemption permits an ESOP to acquire qualifying employer securities, but the transaction must satisfy applicable requirements, including the requirement that the plan pay no more than adequate consideration.

For securities traded on a recognized market, market quotations generally provide the starting point for determining adequate consideration. Privately held company stock presents a more difficult question because there is no active market continuously setting a price.

For an asset without a generally recognized market, ERISA section 3(18) defines adequate consideration as the asset’s fair market value, determined in good faith by the trustee or named fiduciary in accordance with the plan and applicable regulations. The responsibility ultimately rests with the fiduciary, even when the fiduciary engages an independent valuation adviser.[2]

This distinction is fundamental. An appraiser develops an opinion of value. The ESOP fiduciary must decide whether the ESOP should enter into the transaction, at what price, and on what terms.

In practice, that decision requires more than identifying a point estimate in an appraisal report. It requires evaluating the quality of the information supplied to the appraiser, the reasonableness of management’s forecasts, the company’s risks and opportunities, the proposed financing, and other transaction terms that may affect the value received by the ESOP.

What the Retire Through Ownership Act Changes

The Act amended ERISA section 3(18), codified at 29 U.S.C. § 1002(18), by adding an express rule addressing an ESOP fiduciary’s use of an independent valuation.

Under the amended statute, an ESOP fiduciary may make a good-faith reliance on a valuation provided by an independent valuation expert or business appraiser that relied on the principles and methodologies in Revenue Ruling 59-60. The amendment applies to covered determinations made on or after October 15, 2026.[3]

The principal elements of the amendment can be summarized as follows:

Issue

Statutory clarification

Who may rely on the valuation?

A fiduciary of an ESOP.

Who must provide it?

An independent valuation expert or business appraiser.

What standard applies to the reliance?

The fiduciary’s reliance must be in good faith.

What valuation framework must be used?

The principles and methodologies of Revenue Ruling 59-60, as subsequently amplified or modified by the IRS.

What determinations are covered?

Fair market value determinations involving assets without a generally recognized market under ERISA section 3(18).

When does the amendment apply?

To covered determinations made on or after October 15, 2026.

The amendment places statutory emphasis on a framework that valuation professionals have long used when valuing closely held businesses. It also expressly recognizes that an ESOP fiduciary may rely on qualified outside expertise rather than independently performing the appraisal.

The phrase “good-faith reliance,” however, is important. The statute recognizes reliance; it does not provide that any reliance, under any circumstances, will be sufficient. Nor does it state that retaining an appraiser transfers the fiduciary’s decision-making responsibility to that adviser.

For that reason, describing the amendment as a blanket safe harbor would be too broad. Its practical protection depends on the independence and competence of the valuation adviser, the application of appropriate valuation principles, the reliability of the underlying information, and the fiduciary’s own process.

What Revenue Ruling 59-60 Contributes

Revenue Ruling 59-60 was originally issued to provide guidance for valuing shares of closely held corporations for estate and gift tax purposes. Its principles have also been used in valuing closely held employer securities held by qualified retirement plans. IRS guidance emphasizes that the relevant factors are not exclusive, that other considerations may be appropriate, and that not every listed factor will carry equal significance in every valuation.[4]

At a high level, Revenue Ruling 59-60 directs attention to relevant facts and circumstances, including:

  • the nature and history of the business;
  • the general economic outlook and conditions in the company’s industry;
  • the company’s financial condition and the book value of its stock;
  • the company’s earning capacity;
  • its dividend-paying capacity;
  • the existence and value of goodwill and other intangible assets;
  • prior sales of the company’s stock and the size of the block being valued; and
  • the market prices of comparable publicly traded companies, when meaningful comparisons are available.

These considerations do not constitute a mechanical checklist. A mature manufacturing company with significant capital requirements may present different valuation issues from a professional services business whose value depends heavily on a small number of executives or customer relationships. Similarly, a company with recurring revenue and a diversified customer base may warrant different assumptions than a company whose results are concentrated in a few contracts or affected by significant cyclicality.

Revenue Ruling 59-60 therefore supplies a framework for informed judgment—not a formula that automatically produces the correct answer. Valuation methods and the weight assigned to them must reflect the specific company, interest being valued, transaction structure, and valuation date.

What the Act Does Not Change

The Act identifies several limits expressly. It provides that the new reliance provision does not:

  • modify an ESOP fiduciary’s obligations under ERISA section 404;
  • prevent the Department of Labor from issuing regulations interpreting the new provision through the applicable federal rulemaking process; or
  • expand the Department’s authority over adequate consideration beyond the authority it possessed before October 15, 2026.[5]

These limitations preserve the broader fiduciary framework governing an ESOP trustee’s conduct.

ERISA section 404 requires fiduciaries to act prudently and loyally for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to plan participants and beneficiaries and defraying reasonable plan expenses. In the valuation context, those duties have several practical consequences.[6]

Independence Still Matters

The valuation must be provided by an independent valuation expert or business appraiser. Independence should be evaluated in substance, not merely through a contractual label.

The fiduciary should understand the appraiser’s relationships with the company, selling shareholders, transaction advisers, lenders, and other parties. Compensation arrangements and the scope of any prior or concurrent engagements should also be considered for potential conflicts.

Adviser Selection Requires a Prudent Process

A fiduciary should select an appraiser based on relevant experience, qualifications, resources, and independence. The fact that an adviser is recommended by the company or another transaction participant does not relieve the fiduciary of the responsibility to evaluate that adviser.

The fiduciary should also define the engagement carefully, confirm that the appraiser has access to the necessary information, and monitor the adviser’s work as the transaction develops.

Reliance Does Not Mean Passive Acceptance

A trustee need not become a valuation professional. Nevertheless, good-faith reliance should involve more than receiving a final report and accepting its conclusion.

The trustee and its advisers should critically assess significant assumptions and ask appropriate questions. These may include:

  • Are management’s revenue and margin projections consistent with historical performance?
  • What supports anticipated growth rates?
  • Have nonrecurring income and expenses been normalized appropriately?
  • Do forecasts account for required capital expenditures and working-capital needs?
  • How sensitive is the valuation to changes in discount rates, terminal growth, or projected performance?
  • Have customer, supplier, geographic, regulatory, or personnel concentrations been addressed?
  • Do the selected comparable companies and transactions provide meaningful benchmarks?

The depth of that review will depend on the circumstances, but the fiduciary should be able to explain why its reliance was reasonable.

Price Is Not the Only Relevant Term

An ESOP transaction cannot always be evaluated by comparing the purchase price with an appraisal’s headline value. Financing and other contractual rights may affect the economics of the transaction and the value received by the ESOP.

Relevant terms may include:

  • senior transaction debt and its repayment requirements;
  • seller notes, including interest rates, payment priority, and maturity;
  • warrants or other equity-linked rights issued to sellers or financing sources;
  • indemnification rights and limitations;
  • purchase-price adjustments or contingent consideration;
  • voting and governance rights;
  • restrictions on future corporate actions; and
  • the company’s expected liquidity following closing.

A transaction priced within an appraised range may still require careful examination if its financing structure places substantial pressure on the company or if ancillary rights transfer meaningful economic value to other parties.

Documentation Remains Essential

The statute does not prescribe a particular fiduciary record. As a practical matter, however, contemporaneous documentation can demonstrate the process the fiduciary followed and the information it considered.

That record may include adviser-selection materials, conflict reviews, diligence requests, meeting minutes, written analyses, questions presented to the appraiser, revised valuation materials, and the reasons for negotiating or accepting significant transaction terms.

The objective is not to create paperwork for its own sake. It is to preserve a clear account of how the fiduciary reached an informed decision.

Practical Implications for Sellers and Company Leadership

Selling shareholders and company leadership should expect the valuation and fiduciary review process to remain rigorous. The amendment does not reduce the need for reliable information or thoughtful transaction preparation.

Management forecasts are often central to an income-based valuation. Those forecasts should reflect supportable assumptions rather than transaction-driven optimism. Management should be prepared to explain historical variances, projected growth, margin changes, anticipated hiring, working-capital requirements, and significant capital expenditures.

Companies should also identify issues that may affect risk and value, including:

  • concentration among customers, suppliers, products, or markets;
  • dependence on founders or other key employees;
  • management succession and retention plans;
  • pending or threatened litigation;
  • regulatory or licensing risks;
  • cyclicality and sensitivity to economic conditions;
  • deferred capital expenditures or technology investments; and
  • the availability of cash flow to service transaction debt.

The ESOP trustee may also evaluate how post-closing governance will operate. Board composition, management incentives, shareholder rights, and oversight procedures can be relevant when assessing the company’s expected performance and the ESOP’s position as a shareholder.

Early preparation can improve the quality and efficiency of the process. It should not, however, be used to engineer a predetermined value. The purpose is to provide complete, consistent, and supportable information that permits the independent appraiser and fiduciary to conduct their respective analyses.

Practical Implications for ESOP Trustees and Fiduciaries

For trustees, the Act supports reliance on independent valuation expertise while reinforcing the importance of process.

Before relying on a valuation, a trustee should consider whether:

  1. the appraiser is qualified and genuinely independent;
  2. the appraiser received sufficiently complete and reliable information;
  3. Revenue Ruling 59-60 principles and other appropriate methodologies were applied to the relevant facts;
  4. material assumptions and management projections were critically examined;
  5. the valuation reflects the capital structure and rights associated with the shares being acquired;
  6. the purchase price and all material transaction terms were negotiated in the ESOP’s interest; and
  7. the basis for the trustee’s decision is documented contemporaneously.

The new statutory language does not require the trustee to duplicate the appraiser’s analysis. It does, however, leave the trustee responsible for deciding whether reliance is appropriate and whether the transaction, viewed as a whole, is prudent and fair to the ESOP.

Key Takeaways

  • The Act provides meaningful statutory clarity. An ESOP fiduciary may rely in good faith on an independent valuation applying the principles and methodologies of Revenue Ruling 59-60.
  • The amendment is not an automatic safe harbor. The existence of an appraisal does not, by itself, establish adequate consideration or validate the transaction price.
  • ERISA section 404 continues to apply. The Act expressly preserves the fiduciary’s duties, including the duties of prudence and loyalty.
  • Revenue Ruling 59-60 is a flexible analytical framework. It requires consideration of relevant facts and circumstances rather than application of a rigid formula.
  • The entire transaction matters. Financing, seller notes, warrants, governance rights, and other material terms may affect overall fairness and value.
  • A documented process remains critical. Adviser selection, diligence, critical review, negotiation, conflict management, and reasoned decision-making should be reflected in the fiduciary record.

The Retire Through Ownership Act gives ESOP fiduciaries clearer statutory footing for relying on qualified independent valuation professionals. It does not replace fiduciary judgment. The durability of an ESOP transaction will continue to depend on the quality of the appraisal, the integrity of the underlying information, and the prudence of the process used to evaluate and negotiate the transaction.

The next article in this series will examine that process more closely: what an ESOP trustee should do before relying on an independent valuation, from selecting and overseeing the appraiser to evaluating projections, testing assumptions, negotiating transaction terms, and documenting the final decision.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, investment, or valuation advice. The application of ERISA, the Internal Revenue Code, and other laws depends on the particular facts and circumstances. Readers should consult qualified legal, tax, financial, and valuation advisers regarding specific transactions or circumstances.


References 

[1] govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ124/html/PLAW-119publ124.htm

[2] 29 U.S.C. § 1002: Definitions

[3] govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ124/html/PLAW-119publ124.htm

[4] See Rev. Rul. 59-60, 1959-1 C.B. 237; Internal Revenue Service, Internal Revenue Manual §4.48.4, Business Valuation Guidelines (https://www.irs.gov/irm/part4/irm_04-048-004)

[5] govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ124/html/PLAW-119publ124.htm

[6] https://uscode.house.gov/us/usc/t29/s1104/

Mentioned

The contents of this publication are intended for general information only and should not be construed as legal advice or a legal opinion on specific facts and circumstances. Copyright 2026.

Jump to Page

Kaufman & Canoles, P.C. Cookie Preference Center

Your Privacy

When you visit our website, we use cookies on your browser to collect information. The information collected might relate to you, your preferences, or your device, and is mostly used to make the site work as you expect it to and to provide a more personalized web experience. For more information about how we use Cookies, please see our Privacy Policy.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Always Active

Necessary cookies enable core functionality such as security, network management, and accessibility. These cookies may only be disabled by changing your browser settings, but this may affect how the website functions.

Functional Cookies

Always Active

Some functions of the site require remembering user choices, for example your cookie preference, or keyword search highlighting. These do not store any personal information.

Form Submissions

Always Active

When submitting your data, for example on a contact form or event registration, a cookie might be used to monitor the state of your submission across pages.

Performance Cookies

Performance cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage. We access and process information from these cookies at an aggregate level.

Powered by Firmseek